Early Humans Settled
India Before Europe,
National Geographic News: Brian
Vastag: November 14, 2005:
Modern humans migrated out of Africa and into India much
earlier than once believed, driving older hominids in present-day India to
extinction and creating some of the earliest art and architecture, a new
The research places modern humans in India tens of thousands of years before
their arrival in Europe.
University of Cambridge researchers Michael Petraglia and Hannah James
developed the new theory after analyzing decades' worth of existing
fieldwork in India. They outline their research in the journal Current
"He's putting all the pieces together, which no one has done before," Sheela
Athreya, an anthropologist at Texas A&M University, said of Petraglia.
Modern humans arrived in Europe around 40,000 years ago, leaving behind cave
paintings, jewelry, and evidence that they drove the Neandertals to
Petraglia and James argue that similar events took place in India when
modern humans arrived there about 70,000 years ago.
The Indian subcontinent was once home to Homo heidelbergensis, a hominid
species that left Africa about 800,000 years ago, Petraglia explained.
"I realized that, my god, modern humans might have wiped out Homo
heidelbergensis in India," he said. "Modern humans may have been responsible
for wiping out all sorts of ancestors around the world."
"Our model of India is talking about that entire wave of dispersal," he
added. "[T]hat's a huge implication for paleoanthropology and human
A New Model
Petraglia and James reached their conclusions by pulling together fossils,
artifacts, and genetic data.
The evidence points to an early human migration through the Middle East and
into India, arriving in Australia by 45,000 to 60,000 years ago, they say.
Their model begins about 250,000 years ago, when Homo heidelbergensis
arrived in India toting crude stone tools. Digs in central India in the
1980s turned up skeletal remains of the species, and other sites revealed
almond-shaped hand axes chipped from stone.
Meanwhile in Africa modern humans arose about 190,000 years ago, most
archaeologists believe. These humans too developed stone tools.
Scattered evidence, such as red ochre—perhaps used as body paint—suggests
early African humans also dabbled in the creative arts.
The new theory posits that as much as 70,000 years ago, a group of these
modern humans migrated east, arriving in India with technology comparable to
that developed by Homo heidelbergensis.
"The tools were not so different," Petraglia says. "The technology that the
moderns had wasn't of a great advantage over what [Homo heidelbergensis]
But modern humans outcompeted the natives, slowly but inexorably driving
them to extinction, Petraglia says. "It's just like the story in Western
Europe, where [modern humans] drove Neandertals to extinction," he says.
The modern humans who colonized India may also have been responsible for the
disappearance of the so-called Hobbits, whose fossilized bones were
discovered recently on the Indonesian island of Flores.
But Athreya of Texas A&M argues that the evidence for such a "replacement
event" in India remains weak.
"You have to explain the reasons for the replacement, [such as] technical
superiority," she said.
"The genetic evidence shows there were multiple migrations out of Africa, so
there would have been multiple migrations into [India]. But I think these
migrating populations didn't completely replace the indigenous group."
Petraglia and James's report presents evidence of creativity and culture in
India starting about 45,000 years ago. Sophisticated stone blades arrive
first, along with rudimentary stone architecture.
Beads, red ochre paint, ostrich shell jewelry, and perhaps even shrines to
long-lost gods—the hallmarks of an early symbolic culture—appear by 28,500
This slow change is in contrast to what many scientists believe played out
in Europe. Modern humans blew through the continent like a storm about
40,000 years ago, and Neandertals quickly disappeared.
The switch happened so rapidly—as evidenced by the sudden arrival of
advanced stone tools and an explosion of cave painting and other art—that
anthropologists call it the "human revolution."
"What we have is a much patchier, very slow and gradual accumulation of what
we call modern human behavior in South Asia," Petraglia says.
"And that just simply means that culture developed in a slightly different
way in South Asia than it did in Western Europe."
A dearth of fossils and artifacts in India makes Petraglia and James's
research even more valuable, writes Robin Dennell, professor of archeology
at the University of Sheffield, in a comment accompanying the study.
The subcontinent has produced just one set of early Homo sapiens fossils,
found in a cave in Sri Lanka and dated to about 36,000 years ago.
Despite this, Petraglia hopes his analysis throws new light onto early human
history in India.
"We're trying to give a wake up call to anthropologists … saying that we
have to be looking at all parts of the world," he says.
"If we really want to tell the story of human evolution we've got to bring
all parts of the world into the story."
Free E-Mail News Updates
Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks
we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see